Name: Judibry reviewed Chapter 1 on Aug 15, 2006 04:03 pm
I agree
It doesn't make sense that she would spend so much time on something that isn't important.

What's weird is that they are immoral, but Mrs. W and the girls giggle about them and WWW sells them.
Name: mugglemum reviewed Chapter 1 on Aug 15, 2006 12:27 pm
I like what you are saying. I to think that Love Potions played a big part in this book. I also think that we might find out that Hermione was doseing Harry with Love Potions and it may come out in the last book. Heres hoping :) It would make a great story line and may break up the Trio. But only the great J.K. knows for sure. Great fodder for thinking.
Name: tudorrose1533 reviewed Chapter 1 on Aug 15, 2006 09:20 am
Great essay. Really convincing, and very neutral in terms of ships, so nobody could accuse you of wanting things to work out such-and-such a way for D/G purposes!

And very well thought out, as well. I never connect the books that well, frankly...I just don't see the arcs, but you do. :-)
Name: beckysue2 reviewed Chapter 1 on Aug 15, 2006 08:44 am
very insightful, as always! great job!
Name: WG reviewed Chapter 1 on Aug 15, 2006 04:10 am
The trip to Vegas would have been worth it just to hear u present this. Great work!
Name: Anya reviewed Chapter 1 on Aug 15, 2006 12:39 am
I wish I could've been there... Oh blast the exchange rates and such!
JKR wouldn't do that? Sure. The same way we could think she wouldn't kill Sirius, or Dumbledore, and she did it, didn't she? The whole thing about the emotional journey gets straight to the point, to what are these books. It's not hard to see the growing of the characters during the whole story, as goes the growing of the readers of such story. And since JKR doesn't spend a lot babbling about physical growth, it's not hard to see the maturity grownth of all of them. Sirius was immature, a bad example for all, and ended up accordingly, Dumbledore had to die, cause both Harry and Draco needed this experience, mostly Harry since he'd never been alone the whole series. Now we just have to wait and see.
*adding some cookies to Anise's side of the bet, now you can get her $100.00 and all the chocolate-chip cookies you can eat, willing to bet?*
Name: jandjsalmon reviewed Chapter 1 on Aug 14, 2006 05:59 pm
Interesting. (As I find all your work of course) We talk so often about Harry's emotional journey, but you're right, it's one for Draco as well (despite the lack of love from JKR).
You must login (register) to review.