imelda [Contact]

Real name:
Registered: Mar 24, 2005
Membership status: Member

Reviews by imelda

Misconceptions by Hearts Cadence    (Reviews - 704)

Malfoy is acting suspiciously, and the Trio immediately assumes the worst. However, when Blaise Zabini offers Ginny a different perspective, she begins to wonder if maybe all of their beliefs concerning Draco are just...misconceptions. But that's only the beginning.
Category: Long and Completed
Rating: Definitely Naughty
Characters: Blaise Zabini (boy), Draco Malfoy, Ginny Weasley, Harry Potter, Hermione Granger, Lucius Malfoy, Luna Lovegood, Molly Weasley, Pansy Parkinson, Ron Weasley
Compliant with: None
Era: Hogwarts-era
Genres: Action, Drama, Humor, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: Yes
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 45 | Word count: 204764 | Read count: 446974 | Published: Jan 02, 2006 | Updated: Mar 05, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jan 21, 2006 Title: Chapter 38: Saying Goodbye

*Sigh.* No, it wasn't an overload, it was much-needed fluff after a period of so much angst. I didn't realize how quickly you update!! I just found this fic a couple of days ago, and I'm very glad I did.

I was wondering though...there IS one canon spell we've seen that can reverse the Avada Kedavra. Well, not really a spell, but an action. Is what happened to Harry as a baby going to play part of Draco's spell? (I don't want to say anything more specific, in case it is)

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jan 28, 2006 Title: Chapter 39: Alone at Last

Yayyy!! At first I thought you were just going to put Draco through some more undignified torture, by making him hole up in the Shrieking Shack. I'm glad it's working out for the best!!

Oh, and gotcha about the love-sacrifice thing. I thought it was such a clever guess, too. ;-) But I look forward to being surprised, instead.

Rock and Roll Queen by Ada Achlys    (Reviews - 74)

Some light dusting, heavy spying, inappropriate sniffing, and . . . a rock ballad? Things are going to get very weird when Ginny and Hermione, super spies extraordinaire, take jobs as maids at Malfoy Manor!
Category: Works in Progress
Rating: Definitely Naughty
Characters: None
Compliant with: None
Era: None
Genres: Humor, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: No
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 5 | Word count: 17649 | Read count: 2138 | Published: Jan 05, 2006 | Updated: Jun 09, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: May 28, 2006 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 2 -- Inspecting

David Bowie rocks! I'm enjoying this fic a lot...on to the next chapter!

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jun 10, 2006 Title: Chapter 5: The Inappropriate Sniffing Chapter

I love this fic!! It is so funny in an outrageous way-- how many times do you hear "Merlin's saggy man-boobs" or "Merlin's unibrow!" in a day? Or even in a fic? Love it.

And you just keep shocking me into laughter--like, "yes, mistress Pansy," and poor Colin's reaction to what Harry was saying, and, best of all, the jokes about Crabbe's mother. Aaahhahahaha.

So glad we got to see a kiss, too!! And Draco is adorable, even if he is a jerk. The two of them belong together. Although I don't know how happy Ginny is to be kissed by him, after insults like his...

Oh, and haha, I just realized Draco calls Mirabel 'Mira.' V. clever!

Lastly--well, I'm not even going to approach the "blouse bunnies" thing. The phrase was funny, but the fact that there's an actual website (called 'titword'!) devoted to names like that...the internet can be a frightening place sometimes.

Author's Response: Hi Imelda -- I\'m glad you like this story! One of my stranger goals for it is to include as many weird Merlin oaths as I can; hopefully I won\'t run out of body parts before the story\'s over. You\'re right: Ginny is probably not going to be too pleased with the kiss, and (not to give anything away) she might use it as an excuse to show off some of that Auror Academy training. Poor Draco! The website creeped me out too -- I googled \"slang for breasts\" and that was top of the list. Thanks for reading and reviewing!

Trick or Treat! by Hearts Cadence    (Reviews - 32)

When Malfoy tells Ginny that she doesn't stand out, she decides to prove him wrong. Trick or treating in the Slytherin Dorms seems a perfect way to do just that.

Category: Completed Short Stories
Rating: Not Naughty
Characters: Draco Malfoy, Ginny Weasley
Compliant with: None
Era: Hogwarts-era
Genres: Humor, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: Yes
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 1 | Word count: 1723 | Read count: 5418 | Published: Jan 06, 2006 | Updated: Jan 06, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jul 26, 2006 Title: Chapter 1: Trick or Treat

I need to stop saying this about your fics...but I loved it! Ginny is so outrageous, and everything about her is entertaining. Her desire to do the impossible, her contrariness towards Malfoy, her costume, her words "You just felt me up by your door." Poor Malfoy never stood a chance.

Best line? "Trick or treat." Hahahhahahaa. Poor Malfoy.

You Don't Know Me At All by Hearts Cadence    (Reviews - 49)

“So let me get this straight – you sic your crazy owl on me and have me dragged away from my mates so I can cater to your completely irrational female emotional crisis? Explain to me at what point you thought this was a good idea.”
Category: Completed Short Stories
Rating: Not Naughty
Characters: Draco Malfoy, Ginny Weasley
Compliant with: None
Era: Hogwarts-era
Genres: Humor, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: Yes
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 1 | Word count: 1743 | Read count: 7283 | Published: Jan 11, 2006 | Updated: Jan 11, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jul 26, 2006 Title: Chapter 1: You Don't Know Me At All

Loved it! The first half was very funny, with Draco being a total arsehead, and the second half was very sweet--fluffy, but not sickeningly so. I think Draco's arseness kept it from being too saccharine. Maybe that's why we like him!

Plus, I love that he calls her freckles. Best D-G nickname I've read.

The Dangers of Boredom by Hearts Cadence    (Reviews - 36)

Draco Malfoy is just discovering that life is unbelievably dull when excitement in the form of Ginny Weasley comes crashing into him...literally. [OneShot]
Category: Completed Short Stories
Rating: Sorta Naughty
Characters: Draco Malfoy, Ginny Weasley
Compliant with: None
Era: Hogwarts-era
Genres: Humor, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: Yes
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 1 | Word count: 3917 | Read count: 6828 | Published: Jan 14, 2006 | Updated: Jan 14, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jul 26, 2006 Title: Chapter 1: Bored

Loved it. Sorry.

Why Me by Airmid    (Reviews - 43)

Ginny has finally been allowed to join the Order. But is it too high a price? Her mission: Baby sit the one and only Draco Malfoy.
Category: Works in Progress
Rating: Definitely Naughty
Characters: None
Compliant with: None
Era: None
Genres: Humor, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: No
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 6 | Word count: 9019 | Read count: 2077 | Published: Jan 20, 2006 | Updated: Feb 18, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Feb 17, 2006 Title: Chapter 6: Chapter 6- Revelations and Realizations

I'm really interested in this fic, and can't wait for the next update. Your Draco is rather unusual--he's not quite like canon!Draco, but you have set up a very good reason for him not to be.

I am confused about one thing--why are Ginny and Draco mad at Harry? Shouldn't he be equally mad, if he was also love-potioned?

Author's Response: Thanks for your wonderful review. As to Harry...he was angry at first but now he\'s decided that no matter how he and Ginny started dating that he wants her...it\'s a property issue. He wants Ginny becuase she used to fawn all over him; he never noticed that she stopped. Now add in her friendship with Draco and his \'wanting\' increases. As for my Draco, I did alot of research(re-reading all the books) To me it seemed that he was trying to be a prat to live up to expectations. You will see the snooty prat surface I promise! Again thanks for reviewing and let me know if I didn\'t answer your question properly.

His Girl Weasley by mimosa_magic    (Reviews - 70)

Draco Malfoy only wanted two things in life: Ginny Weasley and a good story. Now he's found a way to get them both - at the same time!
Category: Works in Progress
Rating: Not Naughty
Characters: None
Compliant with: None
Era: None
Genres: Humor, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: No
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 7 | Word count: 12837 | Read count: 17366 | Published: Feb 10, 2006 | Updated: May 30, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: May 28, 2006 Title: Chapter 6: Chapter 6

Oh no! I'm sorry there isn't more pup yet...this fic is so amusing! It's funny and weird and Draco is so cute with his heart on his sleeve. Looking forward to more!

Stolen Notes by Serenitey    (Reviews - 155)

Five years ago Ginny Weasley disappeared from Harry Potter and the Wizarding World. What happens when she is found, a hidden passion and a forbidden relationship are revealed? [On hiatus]
Category: Works in Progress
Rating: Extremely Naughty
Characters: None
Compliant with: HBP and below
Era: None
Genres: Drama, Romance
Warnings: Character Death
Completed: No
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 11 | Word count: 55304 | Read count: 20370 | Published: Feb 12, 2006 | Updated: Sep 07, 2007
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jul 23, 2006 Title: Chapter 6: Two of a Kin

Fantastic! I'm glad Ginny finally accepted Bill's presence, because her initial cold rejection of him seemed somewhat extreme, and surprising. I'm really looking forward to the rest of the story, and a reconciliation between Draco and Ginny. I feel sorry for the former, as Bill didn't tell him anything.

I really hope the Weasleys now accept that Ginny has left of her own volition, and I REALLY hope you don't demonize Harry to the point where he becomes cruel or supremely arrogant.

In any case, can't wait for the next chappie!

Author's Response: thank you for your review :D her initial response was fuelled by fear more than anything else. i wanted to show that ginny doesnt hate her family and doesnt want to hurt them but she doesnt want to go back to them either. i cant promise not to demonize harry to some extent but i dont plan to completely because in my opinion he can be arrogant and a bit cruel but they are not all of his qualities. there was no way bill was going to tell draco where ginny was as he\'s just heard ginny\'s side to the story (you havent but he has) and doesnt want him near his sister and also because he promised not to tell anyone where she was. bill feels like he’s failed her in some way by not noticing she was unhappy and is trying to do everything he can to make it up to her. i hope you continue to read and like my story. :D

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Oct 05, 2006 Title: Chapter 7: Once in a Lullaby

Eeks! How sad. When are we ever going to see a reunion between these poor souls? I say "poor souls," but I guess Ginny's doing alright by herself, isn't she?

Draco's not.

Loved the scene with Percy and Goyle. If it were canon!Goyle, that would be disgusting, but of course your version of him is much cooler.

And it was great how Draco absolutely couldn't care less. "So buy him some flowers." Classic. I really like your characterization of him; he's a true asshole. Just as he should be.


Author's Response: yes, Ginny is doing alright by herself. *nods* i think the difference between Draco and Ginny is that she was broken and is now fixing herself whereas Draco was fine-ish and is now falling apart. he was holding himself together but now the glue has gone to LA. Ginny also has more of a support base behind her. Draco just has Goyle. Im glad you think Goyle is cool! minions always get such a bad rap. hopefully (unless it gets edited out) there will be a bit more explanation as to how Goyle has evolved into not so thick and a tiny bit on his relationship with Percy. im glad you like my Draco too! im trying to keep him as canon as possible but canon is open to interpretation so im glad you think i got it right. thank you very much for your review :D

Break in the sun (till the sun breaks down) by Peki    (Reviews - 235)

Harry Potter defeats Lord Voldemort, and the wizarding world rejoices. Ginny Weasley's hopes and dreams seem to come true, at last; Draco Malfoy's end in Azkaban prison. But there is more to life than the obvious choices, and as Ginny and Draco struggle to redefine themselves in a post-war world, a chance encounter leads to more than either of them could ever have imagined...




Category: Long and Completed
Rating: Definitely Naughty
Characters: Arthur Weasley, Draco Malfoy, Ginny Weasley, Harry Potter, Hermione Granger, Molly Weasley, Narcissa Malfoy, Pansy Parkinson, Ron Weasley
Compliant with: None
Era: Post-Hogwarts
Genres: Angst, Romance, Smut
Warnings: None
Completed: Yes
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 25 | Word count: 53044 | Read count: 120165 | Published: Mar 09, 2006 | Updated: Apr 30, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Mar 19, 2006 Title: Chapter 4: Chapter 3

I really like where this fic is going. Up to this chapter (3) it's been mostly set-up, but I am very curious about the Draco-Ginny interaction it is leading to.

The only thing is, Ginny seems to merit very little sympathy. I'm just wondering--is that on purpose? Because she seems willing to put very little effort into her relationship with Harry, and wants him to change his entire life. Does she love him? Will we find out more?

Well, I guess I'll go read more of the already posted chapters!

Author's Response: Thank you for reviewing! Hmm...to me, it doesn\'t seem like she puts little effort into her relationship; maybe I should have showed more of it, though. Here\'s a girl who has been waiting for Harry to finish his quest for years, and then their life turns out so differently than she was hoping. I think this is a very realistic thing to happen to teenage relationships - dreams and fantasies are very different than everyday life with another person (esp. one with as much baggage as Harry) and Ginny is just tired of it. Anyway, I never intended to make this into a particularly sympathetic and nice!Ginny. She has an edge to her, the way I see her, which is why I like D/G so much. There\'s the thing that happened with the Voldie\'s diary (a bit of which will come into play later) and a rather explosive character that is all her own, and I don\'t think she\'d be too rational and thoughtful in a relationship. I hope you\'ll enjoy the story as it develops. :) You will definitely find out more about Ginny\'s motivations.

Blind by smprsgrrl    (Reviews - 88)

When Ginny and Harry get engaged, Draco must finally face his feelings about her... or risk losing her to another wizard.
Category: Works in Progress
Rating: Sorta Naughty
Characters: Draco Malfoy, Ginny Weasley, Harry Potter, Hermione Granger, Severus Snape
Compliant with: HBP and below
Era: Post-Hogwarts
Genres: Drama, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: No
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 7 | Word count: 13742 | Read count: 24552 | Published: Apr 01, 2006 | Updated: Jan 04, 2008
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jul 26, 2006 Title: Chapter 6: Undone

This fic is fantastic; I like Ginny's personality and the relationship she has with Draco. My biggest fear, however, is that you're going to demonize Harry to end their engagement, which is unfair. Sometimes things just don't work, even with good men! But then, the 'bad' Harry is a pet peeve of mine, and you know whatever direction you want to take this fic in.

Have to say, I didn't really understand the whole sex scene...was Ginny upset because she didn't get the sex she didn't want? And 'white *something* on her stomach'? Is she not supposed to know what semen is?

Sorry, maybe that sounded a bit harsh! But I was just confused by the whole scene. In any case, I love the rest of the fic and can't wait to see some more serious D/G time in Crete!

Author's Response: I\'m not planning on demonizing Harry. The fic isn\'t about Ginny escaping a \"bad\" relationship to be in a good one with Draco. It\'s more that she\'s finding herself as an adult and as she does this, she realizes her relatinship with Harry no longer fits. Honestly, even though Harry is a central figure he\'s definitely second to D&G. Ginny understood what it was (but she is a virgin), but she\'s in such a state right now that her mind wasn\'t working to recognize it. Also, it wasn\'t that she didn\'t want to be with him, it was just not the right way. She\'s really struggling because her heart, head, and body are all telling her different things. Thanks for the replying!

My Bane by Extreme Dancer    (Reviews - 173)

Ginny Weasley and Draco Malfoy have always been enemies. What will happen when they end up in a place where no one knows of their family rivalry?
Category: Long and Completed
Rating: Sorta Naughty
Characters: None
Compliant with: None
Era: None
Genres: Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: Yes
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 24 | Word count: 26961 | Read count: 106504 | Published: Apr 06, 2006 | Updated: Mar 12, 2007
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Sep 16, 2006 Title: Chapter 13: Plans

This is really intriguing! I feel sorry for Ginny, surrounded by all these nasty Slytherins. I find myself wanting her to spend all her time with Sirius!

I hope you update soon, as soon as the site comes back online!

Author's Response: Yeah, I know it\'s a far shot from \'soon,\' but I might be able to squeeze in an update today.

After(word)s by distempered    (Reviews - 18)

Post-rendezvous, Draco wants to say those three forbidden words.
Category: Completed Short Stories
Rating: Sorta Naughty
Characters: None
Compliant with: None
Era: None
Genres: Angst, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: Yes
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 1 | Word count: 2820 | Read count: 7610 | Published: Apr 11, 2006 | Updated: Apr 11, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Apr 11, 2006 Title: Chapter 1: After(word)s

That was so moving. I don't have anything really constructive to say, I just wanted you to know that I really felt for your characters, and I think you wrote it well. It was a bittersweet ending, to leave him unable to tell her, but to leave us with hope that he soon would.

Fraudator by Imbirri    (Reviews - 61)

Draco Malfoy has made it through school, chosen a career and made a somewhat small niche for himself. But problems begin to surface when he is hired to eliminate a threat that just happens to take the figure of a former lover and her family. Now he must break the most cardinal of rules: Never make it personal.
Category: Works in Progress
Rating: Definitely Naughty
Characters: None
Compliant with: None
Era: None
Genres: Action, Drama, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: No
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 7 | Word count: 20223 | Read count: 2098 | Published: Apr 17, 2006 | Updated: Aug 07, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Apr 23, 2006 Title: Chapter 2: New Beginnings, pt.1

Augh! You can't leave us there! What a cliffhanger.

I just wanted to let you know that I'm reading, and enjoying, and looking forward to your next update. :-)

Author's Response: Thanks so much for the review! And I\'m glad you enjoy it.

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jun 06, 2006 Title: Chapter 4: Mutual Beneficiaries

Just as a testament to how fascinating a read this is, I got to the end of this chapter and looked for the 'next' button. When it wasn't there, I yelled "What?! Only 2 chapters?!"

Yeah. I'm really into this fic, even though it kind of scares the heck out of me. I mean, the Weasleys are going to get annihilated, there's no doubt about that, is there? And then there's the fact of just how basically irredeemable Draco seems, which means that any D/G lovin' is going to end poorly. Added to that, all this cloak-and-dagger secrecy and the little we know about Ginny and...yeah. It's just damn dark, isn't it?

But I'm really enjoying it, and look forward to the chapter, even if I'm afraid to find out what happens next!

Author's Response: Thanks for the praise and the review! I\'d really love to answer your questions, and put some of your fears to rest, but I don\'t want to give the plot away either. So I\'m just going to stay quiet about everything!

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jul 02, 2006 Title: Chapter 5: Princess Penelope's Tea Party

Ohmigoodness! Quite an ominous ending, especially after a slow, uneventful chapter. I was actually a tad bit bored with reading about Evangeline and Fleur, but you definitely made up for it with the ending! Did the owl act oddly because of the curse on the letter?

In any case, looks like Penny was good for something!

And on top of it all was that small moment, those few seconds where Ginny was dreaming about Draco. I can't wait to find out more about their past. Looking forward to the next chappie!

Author's Response: Boring. Yes, I suppose it was. I was trying to lighten the feel of the story up a bit, add a little humor to it. I guess I will stick to the dark and gloomy-it seems that\'s what I write best! :)

In Vino Veritas by Embellished    (Reviews - 189)

Draco Malfoy fancies himself a connoisseur of fine wine and fine women, but a string of encounters with Ginny Weasley teaches him that he still has something to learn about both.
Category: Long and Completed
Rating: Sorta Naughty
Characters: Draco Malfoy, Ginny Weasley, Narcissa Malfoy, Pansy Parkinson
Compliant with: HBP and below
Era: Post-Hogwarts
Genres: Humor, Romance
Warnings: None
Completed: Yes
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 8 | Word count: 18347 | Read count: 62572 | Published: Apr 18, 2006 | Updated: Jun 16, 2006
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jun 04, 2006 Title: Chapter 7: VII. The Finish

What a wonderful scene! It was fluffy, which was fine, but it also seemed really honest, with Draco struggling to get his words out--and Ginny not really helping him along. And *what* Draco said was pretty moving, too.

I don't know how I feel about this being the end...I sort of feel as if we didn't really get to know Ginny's personality. I also expected the story to be a bit longer, so that we'd see them fall in love.

But I'm not disappointed. The ending was so sweet and promising that I did come away with a happy, satisfied feeling.

Thanks for writing this!!

Author's Response: You\'re right that we\'ve only seen glimpses of Ginny\'s personality. But the story was really about the transition in Draco\'s perspective. That arc is over with now. And I\'m afraid you are going to have to use your imagination to fill in the details of their falling in love. Though I expect it will follow along the lines of most couples. And you\'ll get a glimpse of it at least one aspect of their relationship in the epilogue. Thanks for reading and for your extensive comments! I very much appreciate them.

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Apr 28, 2006 Title: Chapter 2: II. Yeast

I'm really enjoying this fic--so far it's been just a lot of fun. I also think it's pretty clever (if chauvinistic) the way Draco classifies the women as wine. The mini wine lessons at the end of each chapter are interesting, too.

My favorite line, by far, from this whole fic was "I was! I just got distracted by Weasley's hair!" Haha. Way to be smooth there, Draco.

The only critique I have is that he seems to be falling pretty quickly with Ginny, without any real indication of why or where his attraction lies. But then, I guess he probably doesn't know himself.

Well, on to the next chapter!

Author's Response: Poor Draco is in denial, and I\'m afraid it will take him a while to sort out exactly what he feels about Ginny. Hopefully his attraction will become cleared to you as it becomes clearer to him. If not, please let me know!

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Apr 28, 2006 Title: Chapter 3: III. First Crush

Yay! The first real D-G interaction of the fic was really, really good. I thought they moved naturally from hostility to camaraderie. Their reactions to Amber's wine choice were very telling.

I'm really looking forward to the next chapter! Though the fic is a bit heavy on the wine-talk (this chapter in particular, of course), I guess that's your thing; and it does, after all, set it apart from the rest of the fics here.

Author's Response: I\'m glad that you found the D-G interaction to be realistic. And this chapter is probably has the most technical wine talk of the whole story, so hopefully you won\'t feel too weighed down for long. Thanks for reading and for the reviews.

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: May 26, 2006 Title: Chapter 5: V. Fortification

It's hard to express how much I am enjoying this fic. I actually groan aloud when I reach the end of a chapter (they're so short!), because I know that I am approaching the end. I can't wait for you to post more of this; it was such a relief when this website came back online! Yours was the first story I rushed to because I missed it so much.

The camaraderie you've built between Draco and Ginny is fantastic, and what's more, legitimate. That's something unusual for a DG fanfic, where the characters are generally just swept away by their inexplicable emotions. I like that we see the WHY of it in your story.

It's nice to see how much they respect each other, too. And their friendly competition over wine knowledge is always exciting. Please update soon!!!

PS-- Is it more difficult (or prestigious) to be a sommelier in Paris than in London? Is that a dumb question?

Author's Response: Wow! That\'s high praise. I\'m glad that you are enjoying the story so much. I try hard to keep the characters as realistic as possible, but it can definitely be a challenge. As to your question, I actually have no idea if it is more prestigious to be a sommelier in Paris than in London. I made that part up. But France is, in many ways, the center of the wine world, so the assumption might not be too far off base. Thanks for reading and for the extensive review!

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: May 28, 2006 Title: Chapter 6: VI. Clarification

Grr!! I can't believe you left us there. But I have to say--do you think Draco's realization was a bit sudden? I feel like his response was a bit exaggerated...but maybe not. What do you think?

It was a lot of fun, btw, seeing Draco jealous, and I'm interested in Pansy. Will we be seeing any more of her? The annoying, clingy Pansy is so annoying, and even lazy, and I'm glad you didn't fall back on her.

PS- Draco's such a jerk. 'Palate fatigue,' indeed! Though I still adore him.

Author's Response: I am probably a bit biased (I *am* the author, after all), but I think Draco\'s realization has been building for some time. He has at least noticed the symptoms before, but has been in denial. Up until now, he has always found some justification for his feelings, but he has finally realized that.

I\'m afraid that we won\'t see any more of Pansy in this story, I\'m glad you like her!

Yes, Draco *is* a bit of an ass. If he weren\'t, he wouldn\'t be Draco. :) Thanks for reading and for the review.

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: Jun 16, 2006 Title: Chapter 8: Epilogue

What a wonderful way to end the fic! I find it truly, truly amazing that you managed to describe them as married, expressing their love, and having a baby without making me sick. Which is the way I usually feel about epilogues.

But the bit about Draco's hidden meaning behind the wines was adorable, and just reaffirms how unique this fic is. As does his being upset about not drinking.

Loved it! Thanks for writing this fic.
Incidentally, do you feel the same way about wines? Do you assign meanings to the wines you drink, and connect them to life? Just curious.

Author's Response: I\'m glad the epilogue didn\'t make you sick! I hoped that the twist I gave to what really is a very trite and overused kind of epilogue (sometimes it seems like every third D/G story has an epilogue where Ginny tells Draco she is pregnant!) would be enough to keep it from being too saccharine. It is nice to know that at least one person agrees!

My husband and I do tend to try to drink special wines for special occasions, but we don\'t generally choose the wine with some sort of meaning in mind like Draco did. We usually just pick whatever we happen to have on hand that will go well with what we want to eat!

Thank you so much for your thoughtful reviews to this story. I really enjoyed reading every one of them!

Crossing into Chaos by Emeral_eyes    (Reviews - 512)

*Completely AU* In a world where Voldemort was never defeated, only a few things matter: pureblood, money and power. All that Ginny Weasley wanted was to survive her 7 years at Hogwarts, a school where the children of the richest and most powerful wizards dominate over others. Denying her natural instincts, she managed to make it into her 6th year without offending any of the cruel and powerful Slytherins - especially that horrible Draco Malfoy. Until one day, she crosses a line, and her peaceful existence is shattered forever. A story filled with adolescent drama, clash of the classes, angst, jealousy, ridiculous pride and love triangles (and squares).
Category: Works in Progress
Rating: Not Naughty
Characters: None
Compliant with: None
Era: None
Genres: Drama, Humor, Romance
Warnings: Blood
Completed: No
Series: None
Table of Contents

Chapters: 20 | Word count: 208337 | Read count: 314717 | Published: Apr 28, 2006 | Updated: Nov 18, 2012
[Report This]

Reviewer: imelda Signed
Date: May 26, 2006 Title: Chapter 4: Stepping Up the Game

Ginny is INCREDIBLE!! While I wish you hadn't had her say 'bring it on,' and I think it was a bit ridiculous of her to wage a war against the entire school, I *loved* seeing her punch Draco, and it was so exhilirating to watch her finally stand up to him, unafraid. She's phenomenal. *Textbook* Gryffindor.

You know, I was totally surprised by this fic. As a rule, I don't read AUs, and certainly not (please don't be offended!) AUs inspired by manga. But I am so glad I read this, because the world you have created is fascinating, Ginny is such a heroically strong character, and I can't wait to see where it goes.

My only constructive criticism? Well, I just want to encourage you to keep it within the realm of the realistic. Like, while this last scene was awesome, you took it a bit too far. In the world you've created, I think that Ginny would have gotten jumped by the entire school body after knocking their 'king' to the ground. And, like I said, a one-person war against all of Hogwarts? A bit much.

OK, I have a second constructive criticism-- personally, I think you went a bit too quickly with the Draco's-really-a-softy on the inside bit. While of course there's got to be more to him, as he's the heroine's counterpart of this fic, I was pretty shocked by their conversation in the Hog's Head. They'll tolerate the bad treatment of guys because it's only 'petty pranks'? Huh? From what we've seen of their blacklisting, they go way beyond petty pranks, and Draco gets a kick out of it. That scene of him making a that student punch Michael Corner was really strong, and you've got to give us way more than 'we want to be different from our dads' to make us believe in Draco. Right now, I hate him, and would rather see more of Blaise. And also, I don't understand this preternatural aversion the Slytherins have to hitting girls, no matter what the situation is. For one, they are cruel arseheads so it is hard to believe, but for another, if a girl hits them I can't believe they wouldn't hit back.

But I hope these critiques are helpful, and not hurtful, because I think this fic is great and...basically just want it to be perfect.

Those are just my opinions, though.

Oh, and another thing-- while it was fun seeing Ginny punch Draco, don't you think it was also a bit much? Ginny is so powerful with words--they are her strongest weapon, in this world where not a single person has had the courage to stand up to the ruling groups. While I imagine she'll have to gather more arms for the future struggle, I think that seeing her tell of Malfoy was much more powerful than seeing her deck him.

This is a very long review. But I can't stop thinking about your story, and turning it over and over in my mind. While I guess I have critiqued a lot of things, my overall impression is COMPLETELY positive; more than positive, so far I think this fic is riveting! I hope you do update "very soon" because I am waiting on tenterhooks for more!!!!

PS-- How much of the fic comes from that manga you mentioned, and how much from your imagination? It might be helpful/interesting if you made that clear in the Author's Notes.

Thanks for posting this fic!!

Author's Response: I really appreciate your comments! I\'m trying to decide how best to respond, because I have SO much to say, because you touch on so many things that I\'ve AGONIZED over while writing this fic, and some of it has to do with info that hasn\'t been revealed quite yet and some character development that won\'t necessarily come to light for a little while... If you don\'t have any objections, I may use this review to write a post on my LiveJournal and discuss all this there - it really helps me to work out my thoughts on character development and stuff... but again, thanks for taking the time to offer such a well-thought out critique, you\'ve touched one some of the biggest dilemmas that I have writing the fic...